Breaking Dawn: A Twilight Farewell
When I first picked up Breaking Dawn, the final installment of Stephenie Meyer’s Twilight Saga, I was filled with a mix of curiosity and nostalgia. After devouring the previous three books, I was eager to see how Bella and Edward’s story would conclude. However, what unfolded was a rollercoaster of emotions—from shock and frustration to fleeting moments of understanding that ultimately left me baffled.
The plot thickens (and not in a good way) with a surprising twist: Bella finds herself pregnant. Yes, you read that right! The very notion left me sputtering, “What was Meyer thinking?” It felt like a leap into the absurd, reminiscent of a poorly-written fan fiction. The sheer improbability of a human getting pregnant by a vampire had my inner skeptic screaming in protest. And yet, it happened. The moment Bella began to feel the pangs of nausea from frying chicken, I was there, shaking my head in disbelief. “No! It can’t be!” The absurdity kept escalating, making me question everything I thought I knew about this universe.
Once we dive deeper into Bella’s pregnancy, the narrative shifts to Jacob’s perspective in what feels like a new chapter altogether. I must admit, I started out loathing Jacob. Just when I thought he was merely a secondary character, his viewpoint opened a new door of understanding. I found myself warming up to him, appreciating the depth of his emotions and experiences. It was a refreshing pivot that surprised me as much as it did Bella. Who knew I would leave Breaking Dawn with a newfound appreciation for Jacob Black?
Meyer’s portrayal of Bella’s torment during her pregnancy was strikingly raw. In a landscape of fan fiction where pregnant Bella is often portrayed blissfully, this was a much-needed reality check. Bella suffers; she is not floating in the clouds of joy, and I found it a compelling narrative choice that actually enhanced my view of the book, however short-lived that moment may have been.
But then, oh dear—Bella’s transformation into a vampire. The excruciating pain described is glossed over too lightly. Number one rule of any good vampire story: the transformation should be devastatingly visceral! Bella emerges from this process as a seemingly all-powerful, Mary-Sue version of herself, shrugging off the brutal nature of her newly acquired abilities. How does one simply get used to being on fire? It’s a plot point that defies logic and reason, leaving me more frustrated than enthralled.
And then there’s Renesmee. The combination of her rather ridiculous name and the swift way Jacob imprints on her felt like an ill-conceived plot twist wrapped in fan fiction clichés. I found myself scoffing at the sheer convenience of it all. It stripped away the complexity of Jacob’s character development, reducing him to a mere plot device. “POOF! Bella’s gone!”—just like that.
Meyer builds suspense with the Volturi’s arrival, but like the rest of the novel, it fizzles. The resolution felt unsatisfying; I yearned for a climactic showdown, and instead, we received a convenient wrap-up and a “Happily Ever After” that felt forced. Isn’t a little conflict necessary for growth?
So, who would enjoy Breaking Dawn? If you’re a die-hard Twilight fan eager to close the book on Bella and Edward’s story, perhaps you might find enjoyment in it. Maybe, just maybe, stepping beyond the bounds of what seemed plausible could resonate with readers yearning for a fairy-tale finish, no matter how shallow it may feel. However, if you seek depth and cohesive storytelling, prepare for disappointment.
As I closed the cover, I reflected on my own expectations. While I didn’t like Breaking Dawn, the experience left me with lingering thoughts about storytelling’s impact and the ways in which characters can evoke unexpected feelings. Meyer’s work undoubtedly sparked a conversation—one that I may not have agreed with, but felt profoundly, nonetheless.
Discover more about Breaking Dawn (The Twilight Saga, #4) on GoodReads >>