Review of These Vengeful Wishes by Vanessa Montalban
There’s something captivating about a book that dives deep into the murky waters of folklore and dark journeys of self-discovery, and These Vengeful Wishes by Vanessa Montalban does just that. As soon as I found out this was a YA fantasy blended with mystery and supernatural intrigue, I knew I had to dive in. Not only does it promise thrills, but it also raises profound questions about identity and consequence in a way that felt deeply authentic.
From its very first pages, These Vengeful Wishes envelops you in a rich, eerie atmosphere. The main character, Ceci, resonates with anyone who has ever felt lost or out of place, which — let’s face it — is pretty much all of us at one time or another. She’s grappling with both her stepfather’s recent arrest and moving to her mother’s quirky hometown of Santa Aguas, where shadows stretch long and secrets loom large. I appreciated the weight Montalban gives to Ceci’s emotional landscape; we watch her transition from a privileged upbringing to life in an old manor filled with haunting legends — particularly that of La Cegua, a powerful spirit.
What struck me most was how masterfully Montalban intertwines Ceci’s personal growth with the unsettling allure of local lore. The concept that “abuse isn’t always loud or physical; sometimes it’s a bard-wired whisper,” deeply resonates throughout the narrative, especially as Ceci confronts darker elements of her past and the curse of her family. This theme of “be careful what you wish for” takes on a visceral quality as Ceci discovers the wishing well, directly linked to La Cegua. Each wish she makes spirals into increasingly dangerous territory, inviting readers to reflect on their deepest desires and the price they might pay.
Montalban’s writing style truly shines here. Her vivid descriptions breathe life into the setting, which becomes a character in its own right. Santa Aguas feels like a living, breathing entity, steeped in secrets that almost vibrate off the pages. The pacing is skillfully maintained, balancing moments of suspense with quieter, more heartfelt interactions, particularly between Ceci and her friend Jamie. Their bond provides emotional depth that softens the sharp edges of the darker narrative.
One quote that stood out to me was, “The more I learn, the more I question who I’m becoming.” This powerful reflection encapsulates Ceci’s journey, illustrating her internal struggles as she navigates the murky waters of love, loyalty, and personal identity. It’s a potent reminder that our choices shape not just our destinies but the essence of who we are.
Overall, These Vengeful Wishes is a captivating read that combines elements of horror, magic, and coming-of-age themes seamlessly. It’s a must-read for fans of YA who enjoy stories with real-world consequences where every supernatural twist carries weight. I wholeheartedly recommend it to readers who crave a tale that challenges them to examine their own wishes and desires within a richly imaginative and eerie backdrop.
As I turn the last pages, I find myself eagerly anticipating what Vanessa Montalban will bring to us next. Mark your calendars for February 4th, because this book deserves a spot on your shelf! Special thanks to Edelweiss+ and Zando Young Readers for sharing this eARC, which has left me enchanted and thoughtful long after the final page. Happy reading!