This Stays Between Us: A Thrilling Nostalgic Escape
When I first heard about This Stays Between Us by Margot McGovern, I felt an immediate tug at my heart. As someone who adores the 80s and 90s horror scene, the promise of a homage to that era was tantalizing. After diving into this book, I can confidently say it lives up to every bit of excitement it generates, and then some.
This story begins with an atmosphere brimming with tension and nostalgia as we follow four schoolgirls embarking on a seemingly innocent school retreat. But this isn’t just any getaway; it’s set in an abandoned town haunted by the legend of “Smiling Jack.” The stark contrast between ordinary teenage dynamics—the jocks, the loners, and the academics—and the sinister backdrop instantly piqued my interest. It took me back to all those classic slasher films that thrilled and terrified me as a kid.
Margot crafts her characters with a depth that goes beyond high school archetypes. Mack, Priya, and Raffi, the longtime friends, navigate their complicated relationships while Shelley, the newcomer, tries to fit in amidst the swirling chaos. The way Margot explores their backstories and personal struggles adds poignant layers to the plot. In this tangled web of friendship and isolation, it’s easy to feel a sense of camaraderie with the girls, rooting for them through their moments of vulnerability and bravery.
The writing style is sharp and immersive, with Margot’s vivid descriptions giving life to the eerie town. I could almost feel the chill in the air, the rustle of leaves, and the haunting whispers of the past as the girls uncover the truth behind the legend. The pacing is spot on, striking a wonderful balance between suspense and character development—one moment you’re on the edge of your seat, and the next, you’re absorbed in the deeper dialogue about identity and friendship.
One passage that particularly resonated with me was when one of the girls reflects, “Sometimes the scariest monsters aren’t the ones lurking in the shadows but the ones we carry within us.” This line, rich with meaning, encapsulates one of the book’s central themes: the struggle between the internal and external fears we face.
I can’t sing this book’s praises enough! It’s not just a thrilling horror story; it explores the complexities of adolescence, friendship, and the importance of facing one’s fears. I believe both the intended YA audience and adult readers will find something to connect with. If you loved the intense, character-driven thrillers of the past, you’ll adore this book.
In a world where horror often leans heavily on gore and shock, This Stays Between Us stands out by weaving an intricate tapestry of fear, personal depth, and nostalgia. Prepare yourself; once you start reading, you won’t be able to put it down until every chilling detail is revealed.
Thank you to Better Reading and Penguin Books Australia for providing my #gifted ARC in exchange for an honest review. Mark your calendars: this spine-tingling read drops on March 4, 2025. Trust me, you won’t want to miss it!